The Radical Free Agent: A Living Inquiry and Co-design Experiment
This is the first version of a living document, and it will keep changing as people practice the role and conditions shift. It was written by Brayden Beckius, with substantive contributions from Eleri Thomas, stylistic feedback from Sarah Newman, and AI assistance for research and editing. Terms in italics appear in the glossary at the end.
Why this exists
Many people already know what needs doing. They watch ecological, social, economic, and political crises tangle into one knot, which some call the metacrisis, and sense its common origins in ways of living that take more than they return and set us against one another. Systems of energy, food, finance, and governance designed for a stable, ever-growing world are failing, and whatever might replace them is still forming.
We are, in other words, in a transition. One way of organizing life is ending as another emerges, and the passage between them will likely be turbulent. Facing that honestly, which some call collapse awareness, can be frightening, yet it is also where clear and useful action begins. Plenty of people would gladly give their working years to helping this crossing go well, but most can't.
Part of the difficulty is that no one stands outside the system they hope to change. We eat, earn, and depend within it. What we can do is see our position in it, loosen the bonds that hold us most tightly, and win enough room to move differently. These ties grip hardest in how we structure the economy and pay for labor, exactly where this work needs latitude.
Because our economy measures success by growth in GDP and profit, not by the flourishing of people and the rest of the living world, this work has no natural home. A salary binds you to an employer's priorities. A project grant ties you to deliverables and deadlines fixed before you ever meet the place or those who live there. Slow, relational efforts, such as listening, building trust, and tending something across many seasons, don't fit. Demand results within twelve months, and practitioners learn to pursue only what a year can measure. Gradually, your source of income pulls you back toward the system you hoped to transform. This phenomenon is called capture. Yet humans designed those arrangements, which means they can be redesigned.
The Radical Free Agent (RFA) is our attempt at that redesign, a role wrapped in an inquiry that never ends. It asks what becomes possible when someone pursues systems change, shifting the conditions that hold problems in place, across nested scales while answering first to a root principle and to the people and other living things around them. Practice, relationships, and a network of peers sustain the practitioner, and their resourcing doesn't drag them back to an employer's or funder's agenda. Rather than claiming independence, an RFA chooses their dependencies deliberately, makes them visible, and turns them toward community, the land, and reciprocity. The method is continuous co-design, in which experiments inform one another and the model improves through what they teach.
The name carries two choices. “Radical” comes from radix, the Latin word for root, so an RFA works from a root principle on the sources of problems rather than their symptoms. “Free agent” denotes the latitude this requires, freedom from capture but never from relationship (see “Tensions we are living with”).
The idea has ancestors. In 1927, Buckminster Fuller began what he later called Guinea Pig B, asking what an individual without money or institutional backing could do for humanity. Its lesson for the RFA is that a life can be the unit of experiment, and that what one person tests in the open, others can take up.
The RFA model will not solve the metacrisis. Instead, it removes a core obstacle that keeps people from the work they already know needs doing. Money matters because it frees them to move, but the purpose is systems change.
An RFA is a kind of hexagon person, Jennifer Brandel's term for those who weave relationships and insight in the spaces between institutions, both where they live and across wider networks and fields. Brandel observes that funders rarely pay for this interstitial labor, treating coordination as overhead rather than infrastructure. Her phrase names a pattern already present in society, and the RFA asks what happens when it gains a direction and a shared strategy. The role holds five things together:
- an explicit orientation, the root principle each practitioner answers to before anything else and keeps alive through practice;
- the metacrisis as the focus, not any single crisis in isolation;
- systems change as the approach;
- a collective theory of change, an account of how and why the effort should lead somewhere better, built for a recursive role that responds to volatility as it unfolds; and
- practical design for how the work is resourced, held accountable, networked, and handed on.
Much valuable interstitial work holds only some of these, which makes it a different role, not a lesser one.
Why create a model at all?
To give the role a shape others can see. Once people grasp what an RFA does, they can recognize it, resource it, join it, and feed what they learn back into its design. Each new practitioner makes the pattern clearer for the next.
The longer aim reaches beyond individual workarounds. A lone practitioner sidestepping a dysfunctional funding structure remains an exception. Together with other RFAs and supporters, we want to build shared infrastructure, such as common agreements, resource pools, and peer governance, that opens the role to many people, not only those with unusual wealth or connections.
Many already do much of this work
In countless places, people already do much of this work, often unseen and unpaid. Think of the community partnerships officer whose loose brief lets them weave a whole valley together, the freelancer who keeps showing up for a local food network between paid contracts, or the neighbor everyone calls when two groups need to talk. A few may embody all five things, and many carry some. The framing gives words to what they live, and that naming is an act of recognition. It also offers the remaining pieces, such as a named root, peers to learn alongside, and resourcing that resists capture, to anyone who wants them.
What we are working toward
The inquiry's task is to continuously co-design the best role and network protocol we can find. Particular choices within it can prove wrong, such as a funding arrangement, a form of accountability, or an agreement between RFAs, and when one fails, we change it. Our working premise is that the RFA model, taken as a whole, should let people respond to the metacrisis more effectively than conventional jobs and grants allow. Beyond the root principle that anchors every choice, its elements include:
- inner and outer work held as one discipline;
- embeddedness in place;
- a coherent portfolio, the set of commitments an RFA carries at once, which reinforce one another across domains, scales, and time horizons, withstand more than one possible future, and meet human needs without overshooting planetary limits (Kate Raworth's doughnut);
- recursive practice, which revises the practitioner, the work, and the model as conditions shift; and
- relational accountability, a network of RFAs that learn from and reinforce one another, and resourcing that follows trust instead of fixing activities or outcomes in advance.
If the design succeeds, the places and networks where RFAs operate should, over time, show:
- More options kept alive. Commons, practices, knowledge, and institutions that would otherwise vanish endure and stay in use.
- Greater capacity to meet volatility. Communities make sense of change together and adapt well when shocks arrive.
- Movement upstream. The rules, funding flows, norms, and relationships that hold problems in place begin to shift.
- Healthier living systems. The more-than-human life of each place, its animals, plants, rivers, and soils, follows a better trajectory, judged by signs of health the land itself shows.
- Work that coheres. Efforts across places and scales reinforce one another instead of competing.
- Value people can name. Residents can say what changed and would miss it if it stopped.
Deeper effects unfold over decades, so we track them as a direction of travel instead of a target (see “Outputs, outcomes, and direction”). The inquiry also stays open to the possibility that the best answer looks quite different from what this document describes.
Why now
Systems change needs alternatives worth moving toward and enough steadiness to build them, and a turbulent transition endangers both. For this reason, the RFA's immediate work has two strands, the second resting on the first.
Keep options open. The foundation is expanding what Indy Johar and Dark Matter Labs call civilizational optionality, which means sustaining the commons, institutions, practices, and knowledge the current paradigm would otherwise foreclose, and building each place's capacity to choose among them. Much of our present predicament comes from trading it away. By optimizing relentlessly for efficiency, profit, and growth, we left almost everyone dependent on a single way of meeting their needs, and we came to feel that no alternative was even imaginable.
Steady the passage. As old systems falter, shocks can wipe out good possibilities along with bad ones, and fear can invite coercive, centralized responses. RFAs help communities absorb volatility without losing the futures worth having.
Picture the transition as a matter of direction. Right now, countless forces push the whole system along one destructive path, and much of the public mood, full of dread and worst-case thinking, pulls the same way. Institutions behave like riverbeds carved by older currents, holding the flow long after conditions shift. An RFA, loosened enough from those banks, can cut another course, oriented by their root principle instead of the prevailing stream. As others follow such routes, new systems form around them. These will harden in time too, which is why the capacity to open fresh ways must itself stay alive.
Two further considerations shape when and how to act.
Act while the window is open. We may be living through a closing period of relative calm, and how we use it will shape what follows. AI and other exponential technologies accelerate the forces narrowing our choices, and a digital upheaval could end this respite as abruptly as an ecological or economic shock. Nate Hagens argues that trust, relationships, shared understanding, and local skills set the starting conditions for whatever comes next, and that such groundwork can only happen while there is still room to do it well.
From dread to agency. Facing collapse honestly can leave people feeling helpless. The usual advice, to start one modest thing where you live, is useful but often seems too slight for the scale of what is happening. The RFA offers a fuller answer. You begin at home and move outward through the nested scales, connecting with other RFAs who share a direction. Agency returns because the work is real, embedded, and joined to a larger whole, whatever the odds. Joanna Macy and Chris Johnstone called this active hope.
Start with a root principle
An RFA begins by stripping away every assumption except the root principle, which at heart is an orientation toward life itself. Traditions describe it differently. Some speak of an inner light, some of love or of God, some of the Dao, and some of interbeing. The architect Christopher Alexander gestured at something kindred with the quality without a name, the aliveness you can feel in a place, a building, or a gathering but cannot pin down in language. Labels point at the thing, but they are not the thing, and terms like “God” or “love” can alienate people when left undefined. For this reason, the model leans on felt sense and collective conversation more than on fixed vocabulary.
Each RFA's root principle will differ accordingly. Everyone comes from a particular culture, lineage, history, and web of relationships, and these shape which language and discipline let them orient most truly, as well as their place in the larger pattern. A Quaker raised in Britain and a Buddhist practitioner in Vietnam may be facing the same light through different windows. Much of the work is to keep turning back toward it.
Put a row of seedlings on a windowsill, and within days they are all leaning toward the glass. Each responds to the same light individually, yet from the outside it looks like agreement. Dave Snowden calls such a shared direction a vector, because it describes which way things are moving, not where they must end up. Complexity science shows that order can arise without central control, and because humans belong to the living world too, the RFA trusts this can happen among people. Practitioners each oriented to life will tend to cohere, without anyone coordinating them from the center. From that common bearing, goals and measures emerge and evolve through local action. Everything else stays open, and each RFA goes as water goes, guided by their root.
What makes a principle fit to anchor the role
We prescribe no single principle. Any can serve if it:
- orients toward life itself, recognizing relationship across human and more-than-human beings, including ancestors and generations not yet born;
- holds more than one way of knowing, both felt in the body and grounded in reality through observation and practical experience;
- lives through a practice and community;
- yields concrete obligations and a design question for testing choices;
- embraces difference without dissolving it, attending to plurality, power, and justice; and
- acknowledges its lineage, tradition, or historical inspiration.
A principle can be spiritual, religious, secular, or several at once. A few implications follow:
- Traditions aren't interchangeable. Kindred insights surface across contemplative, religious, philosophical, and Indigenous lineages, yet some ground relationship in kinship with a particular land and people, some in a single underlying reality, and some mainly in human community. Each RFA therefore names their own root and shows how it meets these tests.
- Science alone isn't enough. It confirms that living things depend on one another, but it offers no practice or obligation.
- One root or several. Some RFAs work from a single principle. Others draw on more than one, explain why, and seek affirmation for that choice in conversation with the wider community of practitioners.
A practice that keeps you honest
Every RFA names a regular practice and the relationships that keep them honest about their orientation, such as a teacher, a meeting or congregation, a sangha, or a peer group. The discipline can be contemplative, spiritual, religious, or secular. It makes room for gratitude toward the living world, grief for what is vanishing, steadiness to act without certainty, and presencing, the release of habitual frames so that something new can arrive. It is a commitment, not a credential. A blend of traditions across the network is a strength, because any single codified approach builds in its own failures.
Interbeing, a worked example
Our first worked example is interbeing, the root principle of this document's author. It teaches that nothing exists on its own and that every being is made of what it is not. The term comes from Zen Master Thich Nhat Hanh and the Plum Village tradition, which cultivates it through contemplative discipline. We borrow it, acknowledge the lineage, and commit to practice over citation. Secular and spiritual settings alike can hold it, and people can both feel it in the body and observe it in the world.
Its design question asks, “Does this nourish or degrade the web of mutual dependence it touches?” Answering means tracing effects beyond the work's immediate reach, including:
- harms pushed elsewhere;
- gains undone by rebound; and
- what happens when others copy the effort without its principles.
The same question turns inward, to the practitioner's own footprint in travel and consumption, and to how technology, AI included, shapes their attention and relationships.
Inner and outer work, one discipline
The RFA treats inner work (the practitioner's formation, practice, and state of being) and outer work (relationships, place, and the design of systems) as a single discipline. Neither comes first and neither is optional, because each makes the other possible and each keeps the other honest.
A practice that never meets the world drifts into private comfort, or into using spiritual language to step around hard realities. Work that doesn't return inward slides toward busyness, burnout, and capture by whoever applies the most pressure. Held together, they form a loop. Discipline shapes how the RFA sees and acts, action brings back what reality reveals, and that feedback in turn deepens and corrects it.
This loop runs through the whole model. It joins the first two levels of recursion described in “A role for the time between worlds,” and it is why embodying sits alongside the outward-facing functions instead of above or beneath them. It also explains why warning signs tend to arrive together. When practice lapses, capture and depletion usually follow, and when relationships thin, discipline is tested less often.
Going as water
Water moving from one point to another goes wherever it can. When something blocks its path, it flows around or beneath, and along the way it still creates habitat. The Dao De Jing holds that nothing is softer than water, yet nothing better overcomes the hard.
In this spirit, practitioners don't set out to remake institutions by pushing on them. They build relationships and shared understanding within a place, so that when those structures need to shift, there is something ready for them to catch onto. Of Bill Moyer's four roles in a social movement (citizen, rebel, reformer, and change agent), the RFA is mainly the last, and relies on others to apply pressure and confront opposition.
The role is fluid and recursive, and if it has a boundary, it is a living membrane, like the one enclosing a cell. It doesn't seal the RFA off from the world. It lets in what nourishes the work, such as relationships, resources, and feedback, while holding back what would capture it, so the root principle keeps its integrity as everything around it changes.
A role for the time between worlds
The RFA is liminal, working in what Zak Stein calls a time between worlds, as one set of arrangements fades and the next is only beginning to take shape. The Berkana Institute's two loops picture the same passage, with one system declining, another emerging, and people needed to care for the first, build the second, and help others cross over.
The RFA's defining capacity for this moment is recursive intelligence, returning again and again to the frames they see through and revising them as conditions shift. This skill lets the role respond to volatility in real time instead of following a plan made for a world that no longer exists. It operates at three levels, the first two of which correspond to inner and outer work:
The root principle is the one thing revision returns to, and it shifts rarely and with care. Johar describes two movements that support this recursion:
- Scalar mobility. Moving across the nested layers of place, from street to watershed to planet, quickly enough to read small local signals as possible hints of wider change.
- Epistemic translation. Turning what we sense in the body into shared language and tools, without flattening it too soon.
Place comes first
An RFA works from the needs and possibilities of a particular place, nested from neighborhood out through watershed and bioregion to the planet. The most local layer, where people actually live, often matters most, as CIVIC SQUARE shows in Ladywood, Birmingham. Embeddedness also teaches a practitioner how the scales interact, and plans drawn up for a region or for Earth by someone lacking it tend to misread the way change moves on the ground.
Being embedded in place means:
- Knowing the place. Naming its bioregion, mapping relationships with neighbors, and learning its history, including whom enclosure pushed off the commons.
- Asking the hard questions. Who claims to own this land, and how did its holders come to have it? Whose knowledge counts? Who bears the costs of change?
- Working toward a just transition. People and communities who depend on extractive systems help shape what replaces them.
- Passing a test of place. Could this specific portfolio of work exist anywhere else? If so, it isn't embedded enough.
The planet is a place too, but an RFA's work at that scale must remain answerable to particular communities, informed by them, tested among them, and returning value to them. There, the practitioner reads local change as part of Earth systems, links groups so their alternatives reinforce one another, and helps shift the rules and infrastructure (finance, standards, and legal forms) that govern global dynamics. Relational effort can't resolve those forces alone, because they work like a race to the bottom. Anyone who declines to push harm onto others risks being outcompeted by those who do. The RFA claims no power to coordinate the parties locked in this contest and says openly whom they rely on instead.
The work is material as well as relational. Alongside connecting and sensemaking, an RFA tends the conditions for life in place, including energy, food, water, shelter, and mutual care. In Fuller's spirit, the question is what they can build that makes old arrangements obsolete.
Relationships sustain it
Freedom from capture holds only within relationship. These ties keep an RFA's latitude honest and carry the work beyond any single person.
- Obligations come with freedom. Each RFA names the people, places, and more-than-human beings they answer to and what they owe them.
- Interstitial, with a clear seat. RFAs work in the gaps between institutions, sectors, and communities, and say which divides they are bridging at a given time.
- Alone or together. One person or a small group can hold the role, and over time it will likely become more collective.
- Hospicing, pioneering, connecting. Drawing on the two loops, each practitioner says whether they are hospicing what is ending, building what is emerging, or linking the two. These positions correspond to the functions of hospicing, seeding, and cohering (see “Nine functions and their signals”). One person can't sustain all three well, but a network can.
- Holding actions. Campaigns, legal challenges, and direct action protect ecosystems, commons, and communities from further harm while alternatives take root. Others usually lead these holding actions, and RFAs name the ones they back, supporting them through safeguarding and cohering.
- Connected to deeper care. Living with the prospect of collapse brings grief, fear, and dread. RFAs tend these in themselves and in their communities, and they link people with those whose vocation is accompanying others through them, such as spiritual leaders, grief and somatic practitioners, therapists, and community caregivers, without trying to fill every one of those roles.
- Designed to be handed on. For each piece of work, the RFA identifies who will carry it next, whose capacity it grows, and what it leaves in the land, ideally lasting civic infrastructure that many people can use. The task is to become unnecessary to each effort, as everything they start passes to others.
You can't be an RFA in theory
The people practicing the role co-design it. No one shapes it from outside, and no single person's experience defines it. Each new RFA brings a different place, root principle, and web of relationships, so every arrival enriches the pattern. We form it by living it.
Living it directly is what qualifies someone to call themselves an RFA. Theory helps, but only practice can embody and test the role. You identify your root principle, follow it where it leads, and watch what it does to your life. You co-design the systems around you and let them change you in return. Then you feed what you learn back into the wider whole. Each path will differ, and that variety is critical, because it reveals how many forms the work can take and will surface approaches no one yet imagines.
Personal groundings and learning logs
Alongside the shared model, each RFA writes a personal grounding covering their root principle and practice, the lineage and life that led them to it, their place, what made the role possible for them, and what they are working on. It shows how one person applies the framework and keeps the common text honest about who is speaking.
Each RFA also keeps a learning log, a shared record of what they tried, what they noticed, and what changed as a result, including what failed. It doubles as the account of outputs and the shifts that seem to follow, which reviews interpret (see “Outputs, outcomes, and direction”). Before publishing it, the practitioner seeks consent from anyone it names.
This document stays general on purpose, and a planned compendium will gather the groundings and learning logs (see “How the network grows”).
Nine functions and their signals
The role currently has nine functions. Each pairs with a sign that it is happening and a sign that it isn't, so the RFA can be wrong and know it. These are starting signals, and communities will revise and add to them. Practitioners name which ones they emphasize at any given time. The outputs each function tends to produce appear in “Outputs, outcomes, and direction.”
Hospicing and safeguarding rest on the same discernment, deciding what to let go and what to carry through, and each keeps the other honest. Without hospicing, safeguarding hardens into preservation for its own sake, and without safeguarding, hospicing lets good possibilities go down with the bad.
Embodying, sensemaking, and co-creating run continuously. Frances Westley's application of the adaptive cycle to social innovation suggests that hospicing, seeding, and catalyzing suit moments when old arrangements break down and new ones form (release and reorganization), while cohering and cultivating fit calmer periods, when trust and skills can grow. Safeguarding spans both. In stable times it keeps alternatives in use, and through release it carries what Lance Gunderson and C. S. Holling call memory, so that reorganization has something to draw on.
Each place also chooses a few ecological signals of its own, such as a returning species, water quality, or soil health, and reads them alongside stories from the people who know the land. Commonland's 4 Returns framework offers a tested starting point.
The RFA also tracks where change is spreading, using a framing from Michele-Lee Moore, Darcy Riddell, and Dana Vocisano:
- scaling out to more people and places;
- scaling up into policy, institutions, and finance; and
- scaling deep into culture, values, and relationships.
Silence in any direction is a gap worth naming.
Resourcing the work as an ecosystem
How support reaches an RFA decides whether they can stay free of capture.
Resource the role, not the deliverable
Funding supports the role, which in practice means paying for someone's time with no activities or outcomes fixed in advance. Some evidence favors this approach. Pierre Azoulay and colleagues found that Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigators, backed as individuals and given room to fail, produced more novel, high-impact science than peers on project grants, and trust-based philanthropy rests on a similar premise. We expect this to hold for place-based transition work too, and testing it is part of the inquiry.
Funders let go of control
Anyone can contribute, including individuals, families, communities, and institutions. We expect most support to come from many people giving small, regular amounts, topped up by some larger patrons and aligned paid work. Such breadth brings resilience, since no single withdrawal threatens the whole and no one supporter becomes impossible to refuse.
Only one expectation comes with the money, that funders agree in advance not to steer its use. In practice:
- Funders take part without directing. Rather than walking away, they can join shared sensemaking and bring the problems and patterns they see in the world, as one voice among many.
- People in place decide. Those who live where RFAs work choose with them how to use the funds, through collective accountability.
- Letting go matters most. The source of the money still counts, but the advance commitment to release control weighs more. Most philanthropy and investment fold work back into the current system through fixed deliverables, rigid criteria, and expected returns. Any institution willing to let go, without piling on reporting and targets, is welcome.
Multiple streams
We picture funding as a living system that flows according to trust and need, with:
- pots at many layers, for particular RFAs, projects, coordination, and communities, sharing resources with one another;
- no single central fund;
- pots governed as commons, with no one taking a profit;
- pay disclosed openly;
- money drawn according to need and commitment, not by timesheet, and not tied to any particular funder; and
- no outcome-based reporting as a condition of funding, since accountability runs through relationships instead, though supporters still learn what the work produces (see “What supporters can expect to see”).
Several precedents show how this can work:
- Come Together CK, a Canadian community group, lets members take what they need, and when money runs short they decide through conversation who gets what.
- Big Local funded communities on trust for fifteen years to pursue their own priorities, without prescribing their activities or outcomes, an approach James Plunkett, Anna Dent, and Eleri Thomas of Kinship Works call civic rewilding.
- Flow funding, pioneered by Marion Rockefeller Weber, entrusts money to individuals who direct it onward as they see fit, without proposals or outcome targets, and then share where it went and what they learned. Where RFAs redistribute funds, they act in relationship with the people in place, so discretion doesn't harden into gatekeeping.
A rigid scheme with a standard salary for everyone can't work. People's needs differ, and they reach beyond staying alive toward the means to flourish, both individually and together. Think of it as a thriving fund rather than a survival fund.
Money that expects a financial return is different. It belongs with shared assets that places govern, such as land, not with a specific person.
A livable role
An RFA who can't pay their bills can't pursue systems change, and whether the role is livable for those in it is part of what we are testing. Yet small monthly gifts are often the first thing households cut in a downturn, so non-monetary support (time, housing, food, skills, and introductions) belongs in the design from the start, and in lean periods it moves from supplementary to central. The model must also open to people with fewer privileges (see “Who can do this”).
Toward shared infrastructure
Over time, RFAs and supporters may turn private workarounds into shared infrastructure, such as a pooled fund or mutual society, common agreements, and a collective reserve. Several tested tools offer lessons:
- quadratic funding, which counts how many people give for more than how much;
- mutual credit, where members extend credit to one another directly;
- time banks, which trade hours of help instead of money;
- community currencies, which keep value circulating locally; and
- accounting for value beyond money, across the eight forms of capital.
Collective ownership of land and buildings guards further against capture, since whoever holds the assets shapes what work they can host. A sympathetic institution can often achieve more by building these foundations than by backing any single RFA, for instance by seeding a reserve, supplying a matching pool, or paying for honest evaluation of the role's design.
All support follows a few shared principles:
- openness about sources and terms;
- honest accounts, with failures reported as plainly as successes;
- reciprocity, asking, in Robin Wall Kimmerer's sense, what the RFA gives back to the places that sustain them, not only to the people who fund them; and
- care when funding stops, so endings don't become crises.
Keeping each other honest
Accountability runs first to the root principle, yet no one can judge their faithfulness to it alone, so a web of relationships holds the RFA to account. Each party can challenge the RFA's self-assessment, and the exact forms are for those involved to create.
Who an RFA answers to
Each relationship sees what the others can't, so none carries accountability whole. Some face the inner work, some the outer, and together they keep the two joined.
- People in place. A circle drawn from the communities the work touches, including some with no professional stake in systems change, who say honestly what it is and isn't achieving.
- The more-than-human world and future generations. They have no seat in human meetings, so circles and reviews make room for them, for instance by asking someone to speak for those not yet born or for a river, as in the Council of All Beings that John Seed and Joanna Macy developed.
- Peers. Other RFAs or similar practitioners, meeting regularly for candid review of practice, workload, and drift.
- Practice community. A teacher or fellowship within the RFA's tradition, able to see whether the inner work is happening and how it shapes the outer.
- Supporters. They stay informed and can raise concerns, but they don't set the terms of assessment.
Prosocial design principles for groups
When people collaborate, certain features make cooperation more likely to last. Elinor Ostrom identified eight design principles shared by commons that endure, and David Sloan Wilson, working with Ostrom and Michael Cox, generalized them to groups of every kind. The mapping below is a first draft for practitioners to test together.
We expect many small, linked groups to serve better than one large body. How big each can grow before cooperation strains is something to learn in practice.
Outputs, outcomes, and direction
Change in complex systems feeds back over decades, yet the role needs to know much sooner whether it is viable and heading the right way. People who resource or partner with an RFA also reasonably want to understand what the work produces and how anyone would tell if it were failing. This section answers both questions without turning either response into a target.
Outputs are recorded, not prescribed
Outputs are what an RFA does or makes, such as a gathering convened, an introduction brokered, a proposal drafted, or a piece of writing published. Outcomes are the changes that follow in people, relationships, institutions, and places, such as a group acting on a shared picture it lacked before, or a council altering how it funds adaptation.
The model refuses to fix outputs in advance, because doing so pulls the work toward what can be planned and counted before the practitioner listens to the place. Refusing to prescribe outputs is not the same as refusing to account for them, however. Every RFA records what they did and what followed, openly, in their learning log. No one judges a tree by a quota of leaves set in spring, but anyone can look at what it grew by autumn.
What each function tends to produce
The outputs below commonly appear when each function is active, and they illustrate the work rather than define it. They are not quotas, no RFA will produce all of them, and places will surface forms no list anticipates.
Outputs matter only if they lead somewhere, which is why the signs in “Nine functions and their signals” carry more weight than any count of activity. A full calendar with nothing changing upstream is itself a warning sign.
How we'd know it's working, and how we'd know it isn't
We look across four horizons, each wider and slower than the last. The table pairs them with signs that they are working and signs that they aren't, as with the nine functions, because a model with no way to be wrong cannot learn.
Early assessments judge only the first two horizons, and claims about the later ones remain hypotheses. The practice horizon stays open for as long as someone holds the role. A sign that something isn't working is a prompt for honest conversation and change, in the same spirit as the warning signs below, not a verdict.
Contribution, not attribution
In complex systems, no single person causes an outcome, so the RFA doesn't claim credit for them. Instead, they ask an answerable question, what changed and whether they plausibly helped bring it about. Evaluators call this contribution rather than attribution.
Two established approaches from evaluation share this logic and give it a recognizable method:
- Outcome harvesting. Developed by Ricardo Wilson-Grau and colleagues, it gathers changes as they happen, then traces backward to establish whether and how the work contributed, with others checking each claim. It suits efforts whose outcomes can't be predicted in advance.
- Developmental evaluation. Michael Quinn Patton's approach builds evaluation into innovation in complex settings, supporting ongoing adaptation instead of judging against a fixed plan.
Reviews apply this logic, harvesting the changes recorded in learning logs and interpreting them alongside partners' stories and the place's ecological signals.
Reviews and direction
Reviews are conversations among an RFA, their peers, and people in place about what the signals and stories show. They happen at natural thresholds, such as work passing to new hands or a crisis, as much as on a calendar. Beneath all four horizons runs deep time. Drawing on the seventh-generation principle of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, each review asks how its choices will look seven generations from now and what they leave to the young.
Because, as Snowden observes, cause and effect in complex systems become clear only in hindsight, the RFA reads progress by vector, asking whether things are moving the right way instead of whether they hit targets, and treats the work as a set of small, safe-to-fail probes. As Goodhart's law warns, any measure that becomes a goal distorts what it tracks, so signals rotate, change in wording, and sit alongside partners' own stories and the RFA's learning log. These indicators belong to the people in place, who can revise them, and no one reports them upward as grades.
What supporters can expect to see
Though they don't steer how their contributions are used, supporters deserve to see what those make possible. They can expect:
- Openness about the role. The RFA's personal grounding, what they are working on, and how they draw on pooled funds.
- Excerpts from the learning log. What was tried, what followed, and what failed, shared with consent from anyone named.
- A horizon-based account. At natural thresholds and periodically, a brief summary of what can honestly be judged at the practice and relational horizons, and what remains hypothesis at the others.
- A place in the conversation. Shared sensemaking open to them, on the terms set out in “Funders let go of control.”
What they won't receive are targets, scores, or grades, because those would pull the work back toward the logic it exists to loosen.
Warning signs
These are prompts for honest conversation, not reasons to stop.
- Capture. Choices rest more on what supporters or funders want than on the root principle, or the RFA depends on a tie they couldn't walk away from.
- Drift from place. The work ignores what the land is showing, or retreats substantially into the conference circuit.
- Thinning relationships. Tools and transactions replace the bonds the role depends on.
- Practice without the world, or the world without practice. Inner work becomes a private refuge from hard realities, or outer work carries on while practice quietly lapses.
- No way to be wrong. The RFA can no longer say what would show their efforts to be mistaken. The signs that the role isn't working, set out in “Outputs, outcomes, and direction,” offer a place to start.
- Isolation. Nobody else finds the model worth exploring or taking up.
- Depletion. The practitioner is spending down health, savings, relationships, or practice to keep going.
How the network grows
The model is young, so we grow it slowly, in the spirit of adrienne maree brown's emergent strategy, at the speed of trust. People take up the RFA lens because it resonates with them, not because they are recruited or selected. We hope to draw from many networks, backgrounds, and perspectives, and we expect each person to decide for themselves whether the role fits.
Kindred work
The RFA will intersect with many other emerging bodies of work that together form part of the transition. RFAs can find kin in these efforts and weave between them instead of duplicating them.
An RFA compendium
A next step is a compendium, a shared home for personal groundings and learning logs, built on open data standards so that people and AI tools can both explore it. It could let visitors question the core model, see how the role takes shape in particular places and lives, and learn from what practitioners tried, including what failed. Among its first entries will be a worked example, a year in one RFA's life, tracing activities, outputs, and early signals across the practice and relational horizons, so readers can watch the account in “Outputs, outcomes, and direction” play out on the ground.
From network to influence
Following the Berkana Institute's lifecycle of emergence, the path runs from a network of practitioners who know one another's work, to a community of practice that shares methods and offers mutual review, and, if it earns the standing, to a system of influence able to shift funding norms and institutional habits. Others can get involved in their own place and at the planetary scale, helping a web of RFAs sense how events are unfolding and learn in real time.
Coming and going
RFAs will probably always be needed, in greater numbers when conditions are volatile and fewer when they settle. Right now the gap is acute, since most people paid to do this kind of work sit inside institutions built for a world that is passing. As parts of the system stabilize, some practitioners may withdraw, wind down funding they no longer require, or found an organization to carry a maturing effort, then return to the role when circumstances shift again. There is no fixed term. Some will stay for a season and others for a lifetime, because no one knows how long the turbulence will last. What matters is that the design permits stepping back, and coming back.
Who can do this
If only people with savings, networks, and fluency in this kind of language can become RFAs, the model repeats the selection effects it hopes to change. Accessibility is therefore a design requirement, not an afterthought.
- Name what made it possible. Each RFA states plainly, in their personal grounding, what made the role possible for them, such as savings, housing, a partner's income, care responsibilities or freedom from them, citizenship, education, networks, class, and race, and identifies the capacities the work demands. Those abilities grow through practice, peers, and experience. They are not prerequisites, and they grant no one rank over the communities served.
- Plain language. Every public description should have a version a neighbor with no systems-change background could follow.
- Lower the floor. Part-time and transitional forms are legitimate, not lesser.
- Redirect resources. If collective funds emerge, a share should go to enabling new RFAs from underrepresented communities to step into the role.
- Watch who comes in. Reviews notice who takes up the role and who doesn't, and why.
Tensions and open questions
No design can dissolve some tensions, but naming them keeps us candid.
Tensions we are living with
- Freedom and relationship. No one exists apart from others or outside the system, so the latitude the name promises is always partial. Vanessa Machado de Oliveira warns that the wish for a clean exit is itself something the current paradigm produces.
- Clean money. All funding draws on wealth that today's economy produced, and we accept this complicity openly.
- Alignment and asymmetry. Even a well-matched funder holds power that small supporters lack, and shared aims can hide capture. We treat that match as a hypothesis to test at each review.
- Audience and depth. Crowdfunding rewards what is visible and easy to explain, while much transition work is slow and hard to see. Candid reporting to supporters guards against this.
- Rivalry. If RFAs compete for a narrow pool of aligned funding, the model reproduces the same scarcity logic. Trust among practitioners is the countermeasure.
- Agency and humility. Seeding and catalyzing assume someone shaping outcomes, yet much transformation happens with no one steering. We expect what we touch to change us, and we will likely misjudge our own contribution.
- Invisible success. Hospicing and safeguarding often succeed through absence, such as a crisis that didn't happen or a practice that didn't disappear, which makes them easy to claim and hard to verify. Partners' stories carry more weight for these functions than for any others.
- Embeddedness and reach. When the two pull apart, embeddedness wins, and this choice carries a cost. The model guards more firmly against coercive, centralized responses to crisis than against catastrophe itself, so preventing large-scale collapse depends mostly on others.
- Bridging and standing with. The RFA's seat between divides depends on everyone's trust, yet some moments call for standing openly with those resisting harm. Bridging can become a way of avoiding sides, and taking sides can close the bridges. Each RFA names how they hold this, and peers help them notice when one stance crowds out the other.
- Human needs and wider life. Growing food, building shelter, and generating energy all consume habitat, so meeting basic requirements can conflict with protecting other beings. As Arne Naess advocated, an RFA reduces life's richness only to satisfy vital needs, and names their trade-offs.
- Speaking for others. Giving voice to rivers and future generations risks projecting human preferences onto them. We treat such practices as widening perception, not as representation with authority.
- Shared criteria, distinct roots. The tests for a root principle grew from a specific tradition and may favor ones shaped like it. We expect practitioners from other lineages to probe and amend them.
- Naming the nameless. A root principle points to something that resists codification, yet a shared model needs words. Held too tightly, the words harden into dogma, and held too loosely, they dissolve into preference.
- Structure and emergence. Premature protocols contradict the model's evolving nature, but as Jo Freeman warned in “The Tyranny of Structurelessness,” without shared scaffolding, unspoken norms fill the gap. The aim is just enough co-created form to keep relationships fair.
- The first practitioners' positions. The circumstances of the earliest RFAs shaped this version. Its claims hold only as far as others, from different places and backgrounds, can test and change them.
Still to emerge
- AI and the role. Which functions could AI support, and which should it never replace? Ursula Franklin's distinction between holistic and prescriptive technologies is one test, and Audrey Tang's view that openly governed AI can widen deliberation is another.
- Plural roots. Who judges if a root principle is fit to anchor the role, including whether it lives both as felt sense and in observed reality? How do RFAs who answer to different roots hold one another accountable?
- Network practice. How is the trust that counters rivalry built and kept across places, and how do RFAs review one another kindly?
- Legal and financial form. Which structures best hold pooled funds and shared agreements?
- Exit and succession. How does an RFA leave the role well, and how do obligations pass on?
- Sharper signals. Which indicators will each place develop together to replace the initial ones?
No one can settle these questions from a desk. People who take up the role where they live will answer them, imperfectly and in many voices.
An invitation
This is a living inquiry, a conversation rather than a finished statement. It will change through dialogue with the people who read it, question it, and try it out where they live.
If anything here resonates with you, there are a few ways in. You may recognize work you are already doing, or feel drawn to begin it where you live. If so, we would love to learn how the role takes shape for you, and eventually, to include your grounding in the compendium. You may want to resource the effort, whether by backing an RFA, contributing to a shared pot, or offering time, housing, or skills. Or you may see something we missed, and we need to hear that too.
You can write to us at radicalfreeagents@gmail.com. Everyone who takes part shapes the role, so whichever way you come in, you help design it.
Glossary
Sources
Abram, D. (1996). The spell of the sensuous: Perception and language in a more-than-human world. Pantheon Books.
Alexander, C. (1979). The timeless way of building. Oxford University Press.
Atkins, P. W. B., Wilson, D. S., & Hayes, S. C. (2019). Prosocial: Using evolutionary science to build productive, equitable, and collaborative groups. Context Press.
Azoulay, P., Graff Zivin, J. S., & Manso, G. (2011). Incentives and creativity: Evidence from the academic life sciences. RAND Journal of Economics, 42(3), 527–554.
Berg, P., & Dasmann, R. (1977). Reinhabiting California. The Ecologist, 7(10), 399–401.
Brandel, J. (2025, 31 July). Hexagon people: A theory of civic coherence. Medium. https://medium.com/@jenniferbrandel/hexagon-people-a-theory-of-civic-coherence-51af7c35dd16
brown, a. m. (2017). Emergent strategy: Shaping change, changing worlds. AK Press.
Buterin, V., Hitzig, Z., & Weyl, E. G. (2019). A flexible design for funding public goods. Management Science, 65(11), 5171–5187.
Cahn, E. S. (2000). No more throw-away people: The co-production imperative. Essential Books.
CIVIC SQUARE. (n.d.). Neighbourhood public and civic infrastructure, Ladywood, Birmingham.
Come Together CK. (n.d.). https://www.cometogetherck.com/
Ferwerda, W. (2015). 4 returns, 3 zones, 20 years: A holistic framework for ecological restoration by people and business for next generations. Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University; IUCN Commission on Ecosystem Management; Commonland.
Franklin, U. M. (1999). The real world of technology (Rev. ed.). House of Anansi Press.
Freeman, J. (1972). The tyranny of structurelessness. Berkeley Journal of Sociology, 17, 151–164.
Fuller, R. B. (1981). Critical path. St. Martin's Press.
Goodhart, C. A. E. (1975). Problems of monetary management: The U.K. experience. Papers in Monetary Economics (Vol. 1). Reserve Bank of Australia.
Gunderson, L. H., & Holling, C. S. (Eds.). (2002). Panarchy: Understanding transformations in human and natural systems. Island Press.
Hagens, N. (2026). What to do as the world falls apart: A framework for action. Substack. https://natehagens.substack.com/p/essay-what-to-do-as-the-world-falls
Johar, I. (2026a). Civilizational optioneering [Talk]. The Long Now Foundation. https://longnow.org/ideas/02026-johar/
Johar, I. (2026b, 4 April). Don't become a generalist. Become recursive. Substack. https://indyjohar.substack.com/p/dont-become-a-generalist-become-recursive
Kania, J., Kramer, M., & Senge, P. (2018). The water of systems change. FSG.
Kimmerer, R. W. (2013). Braiding sweetgrass: Indigenous wisdom, scientific knowledge, and the teachings of plants. Milkweed Editions.
Laozi. (n.d.). Dao De Jing.
Lyons, O. (1980). An Iroquois perspective. In C. Vecsey & R. W. Venables (Eds.), American Indian environments: Ecological issues in Native American history (pp. 171–174). Syracuse University Press.
Machado de Oliveira, V. (2021). Hospicing modernity: Facing humanity's wrongs and the implications for social activism. North Atlantic Books.
Macy, J., & Brown, M. Y. (2014). Coming back to life: The updated guide to the Work That Reconnects. New Society Publishers.
Macy, J., & Johnstone, C. (2022). Active hope: How to face the mess we're in with unexpected resilience and creative power (Rev. ed.). New World Library.
Mayne, J. (2008). Contribution analysis: An approach to exploring cause and effect (ILAC Brief 16). Institutional Learning and Change Initiative.
Moore, M.-L., Riddell, D., & Vocisano, D. (2015). Scaling out, scaling up, scaling deep: Strategies of non-profits in advancing systemic social innovation. Journal of Corporate Citizenship, 58, 67–84.
Morena, E., Krause, D., & Stevis, D. (Eds.). (2020). Just transitions: Social justice in the shift towards a low-carbon world. Pluto Press.
Moyer, B., McAllister, J., Finley, M. L., & Soifer, S. (2001). Doing democracy: The MAP model for organizing social movements. New Society Publishers.
Naess, A. (1989). Ecology, community and lifestyle: Outline of an ecosophy (D. Rothenberg, Trans.). Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press.
Patton, M. Q. (2011). Developmental evaluation: Applying complexity concepts to enhance innovation and use. Guilford Press.
Plunkett, J., Dent, A., & Thomas, E. (2026, 26 January). Civic rewilding: Applying the lessons from Big Local. Kinship Works and Local Trust. https://www.kinship.works/publications/civic-rewilding-applying-the-lessons-from-big-local
Raworth, K. (2017). Doughnut economics: Seven ways to think like a 21st-century economist. Chelsea Green Publishing.
Roland, E., & Landua, G. (2013). Regenerative enterprise: Optimizing for multi-capital abundance. Regenerative Enterprise Institute.
Rowson, J. (2021). Tasting the pickle: Ten flavours of meta-crisis and the appetite for a new civilisation. Perspectiva.
Scharmer, C. O. (2009). Theory U: Leading from the future as it emerges. Berrett-Koehler.
Schmachtenberger, D. (2017, 11 October). Solving the generator functions of existential risk. Civilization Emerging. https://civilizationemerging.com/solving-generator-function/
Seed, J., Macy, J., Fleming, P., & Naess, A. (1988). Thinking like a mountain: Towards a council of all beings. New Society Publishers.
Snowden, D. J., & Boone, M. E. (2007). A leader's framework for decision making. Harvard Business Review, 85(11), 68–76.
Snowden, D., & Friends. (2020). Cynefin: Weaving sense-making into the fabric of our world. Cognitive Edge.
Stein, Z. (2019). Education in a time between worlds: Essays on the future of schools, technology, and society. Bright Alliance.
Strathern, M. (1997). “Improving ratings”: Audit in the British university system. European Review, 5(3), 305–321.
Tchozewski, C. (2010, 1 March). Interview – Marion Rockefeller Weber. Alliance. https://www.alliancemagazine.org/interview/interview-marion-rockefeller-weber/
Thich Nhat Hanh. (2020). Interbeing: The 14 mindfulness trainings of engaged Buddhism (4th ed.). Parallax Press.
Trust-Based Philanthropy Project. (n.d.). Trust-based philanthropy. https://www.trustbasedphilanthropy.org
Weiss, C. H. (1995). Nothing as practical as good theory: Exploring theory-based evaluation for comprehensive community initiatives for children and families. In J. P. Connell, A. C. Kubisch, L. B. Schorr, & C. H. Weiss (Eds.), New approaches to evaluating community initiatives (pp. 65–92). Aspen Institute.
Westley, F., Zimmerman, B., & Patton, M. Q. (2006). Getting to maybe: How the world is changed. Random House Canada.
Weyl, E. G., Tang, A., & ⿻ Community. (2024). Plurality: The future of collaborative technology and democracy.
Wheatley, M., & Frieze, D. (2006). Using emergence to take social innovation to scale. The Berkana Institute.
Wheatley, M., & Frieze, D. (2011). Walk out walk on: A learning journey into communities daring to live the future now. Berrett-Koehler.
Wilson, D. S., Ostrom, E., & Cox, M. E. (2013). Generalizing the core design principles for the efficacy of groups. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 90, S21–S32.
Wilson-Grau, R. (2019). Outcome harvesting: Principles, steps, and evaluation applications. Information Age Publishing.
Thoughts on this? Tell me on LinkedIn. I read everything, and some replies shape what I write next.